Write a Review

Compare products side by side

Up to 4 products, with each figure shown as its maker prints it.

SpecificationReview Mobility Winner 2026NRS Flat Pack Dovedale (P42811)Remove NRS Flat Pack Dovedale (P42811)Aidapt Bedside Commode (VR160X)Remove Aidapt Bedside Commode (VR160X)Homecraft Adjustable Height Comfort CommodeRemove Homecraft Adjustable Height Comfort CommodeAidapt Luxury Wooden Commode (VR253A)Remove Aidapt Luxury Wooden Commode (VR253A)
BrandNRS HealthcareAidaptHomecraftAidapt
Our verdictHeight adjustable, consistent paperwork and a two-year warranty, at a 127 kg limit.170 kg in a 5.4 kg frame, with agreeing documents, but a fixed 42 cm seat.A high, adjustable seat and a 190 kg rating, with no warranty and no limit on the product page.The highest limit here at 250 kg, dressed as an armchair, but heavy at 23 kg.
Best formost people who need a bedside commode set to the right height.shorter users, and anyone who needs a light commode that stores away.taller users and anyone who needs a high seat to stand up from.heavier users, and a commode that has to sit in a living room or bedroom without looking like one.
Not forusers over 127 kg.taller users who need a higher seat.anyone who wants a stated warranty.moving from room to room.
TypeBedside, height adjustable, fixed armsBedside, stackable, fixed armsBedside, height adjustable, fixed armsFurniture-style armchair, fixed wooden arms
Max user127 kg (20 st)170 kg190 kg (30 st), instructions only250 kg (39 st)
Seat height41.5 to 51.4 cm42 cm (not adjustable)48.5 to 63.5 cm (padded seat)50.8 cm (fixed)
Overall size55 cm wide50 cm wide, 46 cm deep, 79 cm high55 cm wide, 55 cm deep60.5 cm wide, 49 cm deep, 92 cm high
Weight6.8 kg5.4 kgNot in the figures we recorded23 kg
PanBucket with lid (capacity not stated)5 litre pail with lid33 x 16 cm pan with handle4 litre bucket with lid
Warranty24 months home use, 12 months commercial12 monthsNot published12 months
Seat widthNot in the figures we recorded40 cm45 cm46.5 cm
Last checked30 September 202630 September 202630 September 202630 September 2026
Where to buyCheck price on Amazon: NRS Flat Pack Dovedale (P42811) (opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: Aidapt Bedside Commode (VR160X) (opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: Homecraft Adjustable Height Comfort Commode (opens in a new tab)Check price on Amazon: Aidapt Luxury Wooden Commode (VR253A) (opens in a new tab)

Specifications are shown as the maker prints them in its own product page, leaflet or manual, read on the date given. Where a price is shown it names the seller and the date. We have not physically tested these products, and no maker or retailer can pay to be listed or placed higher. Not sure what suits you? An occupational therapist or your local wheelchair service can advise.

Links to Amazon are paid links: we earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. How we make money

Choose products to compare